Preview: draft, not approved by the owner

Promotion

How to vet a website and ads contractor with no cases

No case studies does not mean no skill, but it does not mean you can take their word for it. Here is how to vet a website and ads contractor by other signs.

When a portfolio has no case studies, the client still has other ways to check. Missing cases only mean the contractor cannot confirm past work. They do not mean the contractor will fail. What matters is to move the check from past stories to what you can see now: the work plan, access, the report, the exit terms and the quality of answers to questions. Below is an order of checks for a website and for advertising. It also suits a contractor who has cases: a handsome portfolio does not replace these points.

What missing cases can mean

There are several reasons, and they differ in meaning.

  • The contractor started recently and has not built up projects yet.
  • The work was done under a confidentiality agreement and cannot be shown.
  • There are results, but the contractor does not know how to present them.
  • There are no results, or they are poor.

From the single fact of missing cases these situations cannot be told apart. So it is more useful not to guess but to ask questions and give the contractor a chance to show the work on a small piece.

Step 1. Ask for a plan for the first two weeks

A good answer to "what will you do in the first 14 days" is concrete: which tasks, in what order, what you will see at the end, what is needed from you. For a website this may be a brief, a structure and approval of a layout. For advertising it is access, setting up inquiry measurement, a list of queries or audiences, and test ads.

A worrying answer is made of general words: "we will analyse the market", "we will set everything up for your business". Ask to turn it into a list of actions and dates.

Step 2. Agree on a trial stage

If the contractor cannot prove the past, lower the price of a mistake. Offer a stage limited in amount and time with a clear result:

  • for a website: one page, or a structure and a layout with approval;
  • for advertising: a small budget for a limited period and a report on its results;
  • for SEO: a site audit with a list of fixes.

Agree in advance what counts as success of the stage and what happens after it: continuation or parting without penalties. A contractor who is confident in their work usually agrees to such a check.

Step 3. Make sure access stays with you

This is the most important technical point. Ad accounts, analytics counters, the domain, hosting and social media accounts should be registered to you, and the contractor receives an administrator role. Then, if you part ways, the data and settings remain with you.

Ask directly: in whose name will the accounts, domain and counters be registered? What will I receive at handover? The answer "we will do everything in our own account" is a reason to stop and discuss the terms.

Step 4. Ask for a sample report and agree on the figures

You need not attractive charts but figures tied to the business: how much was spent, how many inquiries came, how much one inquiry costs, where they came from (how to calculate cost per inquiry). Reach and clicks alone say nothing about inquiries.

Ask for a sample report marked as a sample and agree which figures you will see and how often. Ask how the report answers the question "what changed and why". If the report arrives only as a general conclusion "all is well", the work cannot be checked.

If a contractor replies that the figures depend on many factors and so a report is not needed, that is not an answer. Dependence on outside factors explains why a result cannot be promised, but it does not cancel the duty to show what was done and what changed.

Step 5. Find out who exactly does the work

Ask who will lead the project, who performs the tasks, who answers your questions and how fast. The name and role of the responsible person are better written into the contract or correspondence. The answer "specialists work on the project" without names and roles does not say whom to contact when something goes wrong.

Step 6. Read the contract and the exit terms

Pay attention to the following:

  1. A list of work and results for each stage, not a general "promotion services".
  2. Payment order: what you pay upfront and what after a stage.
  3. Rights to materials: copy, images, source files of the site, advertising settings.
  4. Exit terms: whether you can stop work at the end of a month or a stage and what you receive on termination.
  5. Contract term: long commitments with no way out raise the risk.

It is better to show the contract to a lawyer. This article gives points for questions, not a legal assessment.

Step 7. Check how the contractor talks about results

Be wary if you are promised first positions by an exact date, a certain growth in inquiries or a cost per inquiry before the work starts. Positions and demand depend on many factors the contractor does not control. An honest contractor explains what the result depends on, what they do and how you will see the changes, but does not promise what does not depend on them.

Another sign is pressure with a deadline, "a discount until the end of the week". It is not a check of skill but a way to hurry your decision.

Step 8. Look at the contractor's own site and materials

Open the contractor's site on a phone. Is it clear what they do, are there a list of services, contacts and sensible headings, do pages load fast. Read their articles: do they answer the reader's questions or repeat general words. A site does not prove skill, but it shows the attitude to one's own work.

What we are ready to show about ourselves

[НУЖНО ЗАПОЛНИТЬ: что KYKLOS готов показать заказчику по пунктам статьи: план первых 14 дней, условия пробного этапа, образец отчёта с пометкой «образец», кто отвечает за проект (имя и роль), условия выхода и передачи доступов. Ничего не указывать, пока владелец не подтвердит.]

A short list for the conversation

QuestionA good answer
What will be done in 14 days?A list of tasks with dates and results
In whose name are the accounts, domain and counters?In your name; the contractor gets an administrator role
What does the report look like?A sample with spend, inquiries, cost per inquiry and a description of changes
Who is responsible for the project?A name, a role and a response time are given
What if the result does not suit me?Exit and handover terms are described
What do you not promise?Positions, traffic and growth dates without data

If you are choosing between contractors, ask everyone these questions and compare the answers. More about how we work is on the page How we work; for the scope of work on a website read the article What is included in the cost of a company website; for advertising see the page Search ads.

Questions and answers

If a contractor has no case studies, is it worth working with them?

It can be, if the risk is limited: a small trial stage, access kept by you, a clear report and the right to leave. Without these conditions, missing cases raise the risk.

How do I check case studies if there are some?

Ask for the task, the period, what exactly the contractor did and which figures changed. Ask whether you can speak to the client. If part of the work is under a confidentiality agreement, ask for a description without the name.

What should I ask for in an advertising report?

Spend, number of inquiries, cost per inquiry, the sources and pages they came from, and a description of changes made. The report should be clear without the contractor explaining it.

Do I need a lawyer for a contract with a contractor?

Terms on payment, rights to materials and liability are better shown to a lawyer. This article does not replace legal advice.